• Closeup of Banana Taffy
  • Closeup of Assorted Salty Water Taffy
  • Closeup of Beach Plum Taffy
  • Closeup of Cake Batter Vanilla Taffy
  • Closeup of Chocolate Taffy
  • Closeup of Cotton Candy Taffy
  • Closeup of Cranberry Taffy
  • Closeup of Key Lime Taffy
  • Closeup of Maple Taffy
  • Closeup of Molasses Taffy
  • Closeup of Orange Taffy
  • Closeup of Peach Taffy
  • Closeup of Peppermint Taffy
  • Closeup of Pink Lemonade Taffy
  • Closeup of Raspberry Taffy
  • Licorice Salt Water Taffy. Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Spearmint Salt Water Taffy. Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Orange-Pineapple Salt Water Taffy Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Pumpkin Salt Water Taffy Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Beach Ball Salt Water Taffy. Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Blue Raspberry Salt Water Taffy Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Blueberry Salt Water Taffy. Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Bubble Gum Salt Water Taffy. Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Creamsicle Salt Water Taffy Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Grape Salt Water Taffy. Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Lemon Lime Salt Water Taffy Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Mango Salt Water Taffy. Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Cinnamon Salt Water Taffy - Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
1 36

Salt Water Taffy Pick Your Flavor

Salt Water Taffy Pick Your Flavor

$2.25 USD
$2.25 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Flavor

Earn [points_amount] when you buy this item.

Choose Your Own Salt Water Taffy – 35 Flavors to Mix and Match!

Bring the sweet, nostalgic taste of the Cape to your home with our handcrafted salt water taffy! With 35 delicious flavors to choose from, you can create your perfect mix for a delightful treat that captures the fun of summer all year round. From classic favorites like raspberry and watermelon to adventurous options like orange pineapple and mango, the choice is yours!

Simply pick out your favorite flavors, and we’ll hand-pack them in 10-piece quantities. If you choose multiple flavors, they’ll be mixed together in one bag—perfect for sharing with family and friends or savoring on your own!

Why You’ll Love It:

  • 35 flavors to choose from: Customize your taffy selection with a variety of fruity, creamy, and unique flavors.
  • Handcrafted with care: Made using traditional methods to bring you the freshest and softest salt water taffy.
  • Perfect for all occasions: Great for parties, gift baskets, or a personal treat to satisfy your sweet tooth.
  • Flexible quantities: Sold in 10-piece quantities so you can mix and match as much as you like!

Bring Home a Taste of Summer – Hand-Pick Your Favorite Salt Water Taffy Flavors Today!

Ingredients

Banana Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Corn Starch, Colors (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Color.

Beach Plum Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Corn Starch, Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color.

Butterscotch Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Corn Starch, Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color.

Cherry Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Corn Starch, Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color.

Chocolate Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin. Contains Chocolate Liquor.

Cotton Candy Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Cranberry Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin. May contain dried cranberries,

Key Lime Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Contains Real Key Lime Juice, Corn Starch, Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color.

Lemon Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Corn Starch, Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color.

Licorice Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Maple Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Molasses Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Orange Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Corn Starch, Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color.

Peach Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Peanut Butter Taffy Ingredients: Light corn syrup (corn syrup, salt, vanilla), Whole Milk, Sugar, Dry Roasted Peanuts, Sugar, Hydrogenated Rapeseed Oil, Salt, Butter (Cream, Salt), Molasses.

Peppermint Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Pina Colada Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Raspberry Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Root Beer Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Spearmint Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Strawberry Lemonade Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Corn Starch, Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color.

Vanilla Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Corn Starch, Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color.

Watermelon Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Allergy Information
Products produced on shared equipment with peanuts, tree nuts (almonds, pecans, cashews, walnuts, coconut), milk, eggs, soybeans, and wheat.

Allergy Information

Products made and / or packaged at Stage Stop Candy are produced on shared equipment with peanuts, tree nuts (almonds, pecans, cashews, walnuts, coconut), milk, eggs, soybeans, and wheat.

While we practice GMPs (Good Manufacturing Practices) to limit cross contamination and reduce the risk of undeclared ingredients, we are not able to guarantee items as free from a particular allergen.

If you have specific allergy concerns or questions, please contact us via email at Support@stagestopcandy.com or by phone at 508-394-1791 and one of our allergy certified staff members will review your specific situation and questions.

Shipping Information

Shipping is free for orders between $150 and $300! For orders less than $150, shipping is a calculated rate depending on destination weight of the items purchased.

  • Packages typically arrive 2 to 6 days after the requested shipping date. If no date is requested, items are usually shipped the next business day.
  • When temperatures are over 70-75 degrees, we ship meltable items with an insulated mailer and ice pack.
  • When purchasing meltable products, we recommend shipping USPS Priority Mail as it has a faster shipping time vs other shipping methods.
  • While ice packs and insulated mailers will prolong the length of time before a chocolate item melts, it does not guarantee that chocolate will arrive at the destination solid. The only way to ensure items will not melt is to order when temperatures are 70 degrees or cooler for the duration of the delivery window (2-6 days).
  • For orders over $300, please contact us at Support@stagestopcandy.com to receive an accurate quote for the items being purchased.

Return Information

At Stage Stop Candy we love the candy we sell, but we realize that it may not always meet our customers expectations. This is why we offer a 30 day money back return policy on almost everything we sell.

  • If you are unhappy with your purchase for any reason, you can return it for a full refund of the product price.
  • If a product does not meet your expectations and you opened it (to try) you can still receive a full refund of the product price.
  • Items that were damaged during shipping (broken or melted) can be returned for a full refund of the product price.
  • Returns can be initiated through the website or by contacting us at Support@stagestopcandy.com.
  • When your return has been confirmed, simply pack up the items you do not want and ship them back to Stage Stop Candy.
  • We recommend shipping with a service that provides a tracking number and sharing that tracking information with us when you receive it.
  • Stage Stop Candy is not responsible for returns that are lost or mis-delivered due to address errors or incorrect postage paid.
  • We will notify you within 48 hours of your return being delivered to us. We will confirm the items that have been received and initiate a refund at that time.
  • Refunds are issued to the payment method used. If multiple payment methods were used (ex Credit Card and Gift Card) we will refund to the credit card first.
  • Refunds can take up to 5-10 business days to appear on a customers credit card or bank statement.
  • Exceptions to the 30 day return window are Fudge (which has a 21 day return window) and Chocolate Dipped Strawberries (which has a 1 day return window).
View full details

Customer Reviews

Based on 5 reviews
60%
(3)
40%
(2)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
L
Lauren W. (Harwich)
Perfect for Gift-Giving

These were great for adding to a gift package before mailing and sprinkling in to a Christmas stocking. Saved some out of the bag for me to try. Very good and comparable to my favorite place in P'Town. I thought there were too many of the multi-colored non-specific flavors, so I may go in person the next time and create my own selection.

S
Sandra M. (Redding)
Delicious 😋 taffy!

I had been searching for a company that made molasses salt water taffy for awhile. I finally found it online at "Stage Stop Candy". I ordered both the molasses and the maple flavors, they arrived by the following week. They were both in the same bag, they were the same color, so trying to sort them by flavor was quite difficult. They were both very good, I enjoyed them to the last piece! Will I order them again?? No. I paid as much for shipping as I did for the taffy! That isn't right in my book, to charge so much to ship a product "Ground Advantage". I've sent things heavier than this by the same method and it was less than $8.00. No, I got robbed and I still kick myself for paying that price! Live and learn....

A
Ashley L. (Atlanta)

I can't wait to serve the salt water taffy at my wedding!!!

We are thrilled to hear that you will be serving our Salt Water Taffy at your wedding. We hope it adds a sweet touch to your special day! Thank you for choosing our product for such an important occasion. We hope you have a wonderful wedding!

L
LINDA T.
Peppermint & Licorice Taffy

Tasty and nice and soft!

Thank you for your review! We are so glad to hear that you enjoyed our Peppermint & Licorice Taffy. We take pride in our taffy being both tasty and soft, and we appreciate your feedback. Thank you for choosing our Salt Water Taffy, and we hope to see you again soon!

K
Kerstin B. (West Yarmouth)
Giftbox

Yummy Gift for Babyshower guests !
Will buy again !