• Closeup of Banana Taffy
  • Closeup of Assorted Salty Water Taffy
  • Salt Water Taffy - How it's made video
  • Closeup of Beach Plum Taffy
  • Closeup of Cake Batter Vanilla Taffy
  • Closeup of Chocolate Taffy
  • Closeup of Cotton Candy Taffy
  • Closeup of Cranberry Taffy
  • Closeup of Key Lime Taffy
  • Closeup of Maple Taffy
  • Closeup of Molasses Taffy
  • Closeup of Orange Taffy
  • Closeup of Peach Taffy
  • Closeup of Peppermint Taffy
  • Closeup of Pink Lemonade Taffy
  • Closeup of Raspberry Taffy
  • Licorice Salt Water Taffy. Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Spearmint Salt Water Taffy. Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Orange-Pineapple Salt Water Taffy Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Pumpkin Salt Water Taffy Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Beach Ball Salt Water Taffy. Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Blue Raspberry Salt Water Taffy Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Blueberry Salt Water Taffy. Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Bubble Gum Salt Water Taffy. Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Creamsicle Salt Water Taffy Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Grape Salt Water Taffy. Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Lemon Lime Salt Water Taffy Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Mango Salt Water Taffy. Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Cinnamon Salt Water Taffy - Sold in 10 piece quantity. If picking multiple flavors, pieces will be mixed together in one bag.
  • Strawberry Salt Water Taffy
  • Vanilla Frosting Salt Water taffy
  • Sea Salt Vanilla Salt Water Taffy
1 40

Salt Water Taffy Pick Your Flavor

Salt Water Taffy Pick Your Flavor

$2.50 USD
$2.50 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Flavor
Size

Choose Your Own Salt Water Taffy – 37 Flavors,  One Per Bag!

Craving that classic Cape Cod taffy experience? Now you can bring it home, one flavor at a time! With our Choose Your Own Salt Water Taffy collection, you get to pick your favorite flavor from a rainbow of 37 mouthwatering options, each chewy bite bursting with sweet, summery nostalgia. From fruity standouts like raspberry and watermelon, to creamy classics like vanilla and root beer, and even adventurous picks like orange pineapple or mango, there’s something to satisfy every kind of sweet tooth.

Each order is hand-packed right here at our family-run shop on Cape Cod, where we’ve been sharing candy and smiles for over 40 years. You’ll receive your selected flavor in your choice of a 10-piece sampler, 8-ounce bag, or 1-pound bag. Whether you’re building a themed gift basket, planning a party favor, or simply treating yourself to a soft and stretchy seaside favorite, this taffy delivers that sun-soaked boardwalk feeling, no matter the season.

Please note: Each bag contains one flavor only. No mixed bags at this time, but with so many delicious flavors to try, why not grab a few?

Why You’ll Love It

  • 37 irresistible flavors
    Choose from a wide variety of fruity, creamy, and unique taffy options - there's a favorite for everyone.
  • One flavor per bag
    Get exactly what you're craving with a full bag of your top pick - no surprises, just sweet satisfaction.
  • Cape Cod tradition
    Packed with nostalgic charm from our family-run candy shop in the heart of Cape Cod.
  • Soft, chewy texture
    Each piece is delightfully stretchy and smooth, just the way real salt water taffy should be.
  • Great for gifting or snacking
    Available in three sizes - perfect for party favors, stocking stuffers, or keeping your own stash stocked.

Ingredients

Banana Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Corn Starch, Colors (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Color.

Beach Plum Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Corn Starch, Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color.

Butterscotch Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Corn Starch, Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color.

Cherry Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Corn Starch, Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color.

Chocolate Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin. Contains Chocolate Liquor.

Cotton Candy Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Cranberry Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin. May contain dried cranberries,

Key Lime Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Contains Real Key Lime Juice, Corn Starch, Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color.

Lemon Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Corn Starch, Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color.

Licorice Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Maple Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Molasses Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Orange Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Corn Starch, Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color.

Peach Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Peanut Butter Taffy Ingredients: Light corn syrup (corn syrup, salt, vanilla), Whole Milk, Sugar, Dry Roasted Peanuts, Sugar, Hydrogenated Rapeseed Oil, Salt, Butter (Cream, Salt), Molasses.

Peppermint Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Pina Colada Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Raspberry Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Root Beer Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Spearmint Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Strawberry Lemonade Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Corn Starch, Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color.

Vanilla Taffy: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Butter (Milk, Salt), Palm Oil, Citric Acid, Salt, Artificial and Natural Flavors, Corn Starch, Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color.

Watermelon Taffy: Light Corn Syrup (Corn Syrup, Salt, Vanilla), Sugar, Water, Butter (Cream, Salt), Palm Oil, Cornstarch, Maple Syrup, Salt, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Artificial Coloring (FD&C Yellow #5 & Yellow #6, Red #40, Blue #1 & #2), Caramel Food Color, Soy Lecithin.

Allergy Information
Products produced on shared equipment with peanuts, tree nuts (almonds, pecans, cashews, walnuts, coconut), milk, eggs, soybeans, and wheat.

Allergy Information

Products made and / or packaged at Stage Stop Candy are produced on shared equipment with peanuts, tree nuts (almonds, pecans, cashews, walnuts, coconut), milk, eggs, soybeans, and wheat.

While we practice GMPs (Good Manufacturing Practices) to limit cross contamination and reduce the risk of undeclared ingredients, we are not able to guarantee items as free from a particular allergen.

If you have specific allergy concerns or questions, please contact us via email at Support@stagestopcandy.com or by phone at 508-394-1791 and one of our allergy certified staff members will review your specific situation and questions.

Shipping Information

Shipping is free for orders between $150 and $300. For orders under $150, shipping is calculated at checkout based on the destination and total package weight.

We ship via USPS and UPS, offering a range of shipping speeds and pricing options to suit your needs. While slower ground services are available through both carriers, we strongly recommend choosing Priority Mail or UPS Air when sending meltable items especially during warmer months.

  • Most orders arrive at their destination within 3 to 8 days of the order date (depending on the shipping method selected).
  • If you want your order held and shipped on a specific date please note that at checkout. If no specific date is requested, we usually ship the next business day.
  • For temperatures above 70–75°F, meltable items are packed with an insulated mailer and ice pack to help protect them during transit. However, please note that while this packaging slows the melting process, it does not guarantee the items will arrive completely solid. To ensure your chocolate arrives in perfect condition, we recommend ordering when temperatures along the delivery route are expected to stay below 70°F.
  • For orders over $300, please contact us at Support@stagestopcandy.com to receive an accurate quote for the items being purchased.

Return Information

At Stage Stop Candy, we stand behind every treat we sell. If your purchase doesn’t meet expectations, we offer a 30-day money-back guarantee on most items.

✅ Eligible Returns

  • Not satisfied? Return any unopened or opened product (even if you tried it) for a full refund of the product price.
  • Shipping damage? If your item arrived broken or melted, we’re happy to issue a full refund—as long as the damage is reported within 24 hours of delivery.

Return window exceptions:

  • Fudge: Must be returned within 21 days
  • Chocolate Dipped Strawberries: Not returnable due to perishability

🔄 How to Start a Return

  • Initiate a return through our website or by emailing Support@stagestopcandy.com.
  • Once approved, simply pack the items securely and ship them back to us.
  • We recommend using a carrier that provides tracking, and sharing that tracking number with us.

💳 Refunds

  • Refunds are issued to the original payment method.
  • If multiple methods were used (e.g., credit card and gift card), we’ll refund to the credit card first.
  • Refunds typically appear within 5–10 business days of being processed.
  • We’ll notify you within 48 hours of receiving your return and confirm the items we’ve received before processing your refund.

⚠️ Please Note

  • Stage Stop Candy is not responsible for returns lost or misdelivered due to incorrect addresses or insufficient postage.
View full details